Diane Borchardt was a former teacher’s aide/study hall monitor at Jefferson High School in Wisconsin. She was convicted of hiring three of her students to murder her estranged husband, Ruben Borchardt, on Easter morning in 1994 .
Aug 24, 2020 · Diane’s trial was much more extensively covered. Many in Lincoln still couldn’t believe she was guilty of conspiring with teens to have Ruben killed. Her …Estimated Reading Time: 7 mins
Apr 03, 2019 · Diane Borchardt was a former teacher's aide/study hall monitor at Jefferson High School in Wisconsin. She was convicted of hiring three of her students to murder her estranged husband, Ruben Borchardt, on Easter morning in 1994.
Jul 02, 2014 · number two, becoming Mrs. Diane Borchardt. For his part, Borchardt had also been married once before but he was tragically widowed when his wife was killed in a car accident in front of their home. He was left with two children. Strangely, Fister claimed Borchardt`s tragedy was the reason she wed her husband, not because she loved him.Estimated Reading Time: 7 mins
Aug 22, 1995 · Diane Borchardt is serving a sentence of life in prison for hiring three teen-agers to murder her estranged husband on Easter 1994. The teen-age …Estimated Reading Time: 1 min
Diane Borchardt, née Pfister, is a former teacher convicted of murder, having hired 3 students to kill her husband. In 1979, 31-year old Diane Pfister met 25-year old widower Ruben Borchardt, who already had two children, Chuck and Brooke, from his recently deceased wife Susan.
NICHOL, J. Diane Borchardt appeals from a trial verdict in which she was convicted of party to a crime first-degree homicide with the use of a dangerous weapon, in violation of §§ 939.05 and 939.63, Stats., respectively, in the death of her husband Ruben Borchardt, and using a child to commit a Class A felony, in violation of § 948.36, Stats ...
Jan 27, 1995 · Diane Borchardt, 45, offered cars, jewelry and cash from her estranged husband's life insurance policy to Yanke and two other youths to kill Ruben Borchardt, 40, Jefferson County investigators say.Estimated Reading Time: 3 mins
Apr 16, 2020 · Diane Borchardt would later tell the television show American Criminal that she never felt a physical attraction towards Ruben, only a calling to help comfort him and his now motherless children. Known around town as “Mrs. B”, Diane also worked as a teacher's assistant and a high school monitor on top of owning her own shirt printing business, Mrs. B Sport-Screen.Estimated Reading Time: 6 mins
Upon realizing their feelings for each other, Claire and Ruben start meeting each other secretly, and contemplate leaving their spouses in order to marry. As Ruben fights for his life, he proclaims his love for her and leaves his children in her care. Diane hugs Doug in her drive for sympathy, saying that Ruben would not do this to her if he knew she had him. David R. Soon afterward, while working as a foreman at Schweiger Industries, a local furniture manufacturer, he began seeing Diane Pfister, a secretary at Schweiger, who was divorced from her first husband. Having carried out their deed, the three boys flee the scene. Flores v. The two formed a romantic interest that soon became public knowledge around the town of Jefferson. He stutters a lot when he's scared. Vest and Maldonado were sentenced to life in prison. She then says that if she were to have Ruben killed, it would have to be someone she trusted, and to his distress, she refers to him. Yanke took the phone off the hook. When Burstyn confronts him on this, Doug makes a full confession, and provides him with the names of his accomplices. This court already decided in an interlocutory ruling that the State was under no obligation to produce transcripts of the John Doe witnesses who were going to testify at trial until the completion of their direct testimony. If you do that and if the Court of Appeals says it was perfectly plausible, what was [the trial court] thinking of the remedy at that point, obviously would be a remand to determine whether or not they were credible. Murderers Arsonists Masterminds. No one had doubt, but she had not physically done it. Method of murder: Shooting shotgun. On the eve of Easter morning, Ruben is wary of Diane's death threat. In one argument, Diane smashed a flower vase on Ruben's head. Prologue The film cuts to seven months before the shooting, during the Fall of She was a good and caring person. If indeed counsel informed Borchardt that accusing Charles was not an option under their trial strategy, it made no difference in the outcome. She claimed she herself was the victim of a conspiracy between police and the DA. Boshcka , Wis. Did she really expect the jury to believe that. Soon Diane became the sole suspect in the crime. She called the police, who told her to leave a volatile situation. Soon Fister wed husband number two, becoming Mrs. Yanke testified against his friends, receiving an year sentence, with the possibility of parole after 10 year. To Diane's horror, she is found guilty of first-degree intentional homicide, and breaks down in front of the courtroom as her daughter Regan looks on in despair. Fister promptly eloped with a man for revenge. You are commenting using your WordPress. The boys then flee the scene and dump the shotgun into a vacant lot. Even when legal proceedings are concluded, some fear that Ruben's murder will leave deep and lasting scars. He claimed he was at home asleep when Borchardt was shot. Doug later commissions Josh and his friend Michael Maldonado Freddy Rodriguez to help him carry out the murder. Diane should share a cell with Pamela Smart , the woman who had her real estate salesman husband shot by two teenagers, or Betty Broderick , the socialite who murdered her husband for marrying his mistress. Police investigated the Borchardt household. Diane then accuses Ruben of spoiling his own children and neglecting Regan, and says that he ought to be making more money. In the days that follow, Diane deals further insult to her grieving family by threatening to sue the funeral home for proceeding with Ruben's service without her consent, as she had not been present to arrange it. There, amidst the air of shock and outrage among the students, the police arrest Josh and Diane, with the latter desperately protesting her innocence as she is dragged away in handcuffs. Later, Ruben and the family go to the annual Christmas party at the Church. Once again, Diane feigns sorrow in front of the open casket to preserve her innocence. Moldanado was also found guilty of first degree intentional homicide receiving a life sentence with the possibility of parole after 50 years.
In , year old Diane Pfister met year old widower Ruben Borchardt, who already had two children, Chuck and Brooke, from his recently deceased wife Susan. They shortly got married and had a daughter named Regan. Diane was a teacher's aide at the local high school. The other teachers liked her because she was always willing to help. Even the students liked her, calling her "Mrs. This included Joshua Yanke, 16, and Douglas Vest, They shared their troubles with her. But the household experienced a different sort of woman. At home, Diane tried to erase all trace of Susan Borchardt. Diane got rid of pictures of Susan and wouldn't allow discussion of her, saying she was no longer part of their lives because she was dead. Diane wanted them to accept was that they had no other mother but her. Diane's jealousy of a dead woman also including into resenting raising her step-children. Chuck and Brooke. Diane focused her attention on her daughter Regan. By the s, Diane became more controlling and erratic. In one argument, Diane smashed a flower vase on Ruben's head. She would call the police sometimes and falsely say Ruben was assaulting her. Diane would assault Ruben and turn it around on him to make it look to the police like he hit her. In , Ruben was pushed to the brink. He realized he couldn't be with her any longer. He found a girl named Judy. At Thanksgiving, Ruben announced he was filing for divorce. He was going to marry Judy. Diane filed for sole custody of the children, claiming constant neglect. Ruben, however, got custody of the children and the house. The court ruled that Diane had to leave the house hold by April 15, Ruben was terrified at what his former wife would do. He lined the stairs with mayonnaise jars as an alarm system in case Diane, who had threatened to castrate him, came in the house to hurt him. They recruited year old Michael Maldonado. With a promise of cash, cars and jewelry, Diane hired the three boys to kill her husband. Vest and Maldonado were to shoot Ruben in his sleep while Yanke was to unhook the phone and make sure Chuck Borchardt didn't interfere. On April 2, , Diane started a fight with Ruben, trying to take a sewing machine that belonged to Ruben's first wife Susan. Diane tried to get Ruben to hit her, but the argument escalated to her jumping on Ruben's back and hitting him. Ruben threw her off him, which did bruise her arm. She called the police, who told her to leave a volatile situation. Diane left with Regan, having official witnesses seeing their departure, establishing an alibi. The next morning, Chuck was asleep, Brooke was at a friend's house. Ruben awoke early to attend church. As he was coming up the steps, Malando shot him twice, then the three hitmen flee, dumping the shotgun in a vacant lot. Chuck awoke and found his father bleeding on a chair. Ruben managed to say "I can't believe she did this to me. Ruben's murder happening two weeks before Diane had to move out made her the prime suspect. No one had doubt, but she had not physically done it. Though Diane thought she had gotten away with it, Ruben's life insurance payout was frozen. Diane was unable to pay the boys, who turned themselves in.
Skip to content. Having carried out their deed, the three boys flee the scene. Brady , Wis. Borchardt was embroiled in a bitter divorce with Ruben, knew Ruben was having an affair with another woman, and wanted undercover pictures and surveillance of Ruben and the woman taken by an investigator and third parties. Fister wanted to join the military after high school but her father refused. The police soon discover that the murder weapon was a shotgun, and deduce that the shooter was an amateur, as the gun was of a cheap design. She then says that if she were to have Ruben killed, it would have to be someone she trusted, and to his distress, she refers to him. Ruben denies this and the police tell the couple to separate temporarily. He found a girl named Judy. Five months after the murder, it becomes apparent to Diane that the cops are on to her, and tries to conceal her guilt. Chuck agreed to be hypnotized but he reiterated the same story. At approximately a. With a promise of cash, cars and jewelry, Diane hired the three boys to kill her husband. She was convicted of hiring three of her students to murder her estranged husband, Ruben Borchardt, on Easter morning in Classification: Murderer Characteristics: C onvicted of hiring three of her students to murder her estranged husband Number of victims: 1 Date of murder: April 3, Date of arrest: September 29, Date of birth: Victim profile: Ruben Borchardt, 40 her estranged husband Method of murder: Shooting shotgun Location: Jefferson County, Wisconsin, USA Status: Sentenced to life in prison, with no possibility of parole until she had served 45 years of her sentence photo gallery Court of Appeals of Wisconsin District IV State of Wisconsin v. Charles found his father still conscious and able to state that two males had shot him. They shortly got married and had a daughter named Regan. It was soon after Ruben filed for divorce that Diane allegedly put her plot in motion. In the final scene, Diane is interviewed for a True Crime Documentary , from jail. Deutsch Edit links. The end of the film is followed by an epilogue outlining the sentences faced by the conspirators:. By the s, Diane became more controlling and erratic. As Ruben fights for his life, he proclaims his love for her and leaves his children in her care. After grabbing her arm in an attempt to disarm her, Diane uses the marks on her arm to claim to the police that Ruben hit her. The purpose could have been for an already-charged individual or someone not yet charged. Once again, Diane feigns sorrow in front of the open casket to preserve her innocence. At first the notion that the study-hall monitor at Jefferson High School would be involved in her husband's murder seemed outlandish to many of the 6, residents of this two-stoplight farming town. Soon afterward, while working as a foreman at Schweiger Industries, a local furniture manufacturer, he began seeing Diane Pfister, a secretary at Schweiger, who was divorced from her first husband. By January , Ruben had filed for divorce and moved into his basement until property and custodial matters could be settled. Ruben goes forth with the divorce proceedings against Diane's wishes. Upon hearing this, Claire is soon able to overcome her personal guilt and becomes an adoptive mother to Chuck and Brook. Ruben Borchardt, 40 father of three and a self-employed cabinet maker, struggles to recover and dies on Easter Sunday a few hours after the dispatch call. To this the court replied: Well, again I think you misunderstood me. Doug, who's estranged father was physically abusive towards his own mother, says that Ruben's behavior is inexcusable. Failing to break in through the cellar, they got into the house through the first floor. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:. On the stairway, Moldanado and Vest encountered Borchardt. Later in March, Diane commissions another student Tim Johnny Strong to do away with her husband, telling him that the one person she still trusted let her down. This court already decided in an interlocutory ruling that the State was under no obligation to produce transcripts of the John Doe witnesses who were going to testify at trial until the completion of their direct testimony. She also takes the family dog away by force. Meanwhile at school, Diane feigns sadness in front of her students to gain sympathy from them. While Diane is away, Ruben runs into Claire at the dance and the two steal the dance floor, and Claire accepts Ruben's proposal. Killers Without Conscience. He will not be eligible for parole until he has served fifty years of his sentence. Josh admits his role in the conspiracy, as well as Doug's role in organizing the attack. Claire becomes uneasy as the harassment persists, and insists Diane is dangerous, but Ruben insists he can handle her. Ineffective Assistance of Counsel. After New Year's Day, Ruben learns that Diane is seeking custody of Chuck as part of her ploy to secure the house, prompting Ruben to confront her. Categories : television films films crime drama films American crime drama films American films American television films Drama films based on actual events English-language films Films about educators Films set in Films set in Madison, Wisconsin Films shot in Los Angeles Crime films based on actual events. By "she," Chuck believed, Ruben meant his wife, Diane, William Phelps.
Diane Fister was born on August 3 An adorable brown-haired, brown-eyed little girl, she was always an independent child. Fister wanted to join the military after high school but her father refused. Fister promptly eloped with a man for revenge. Soon afterward, Fister divorced her husband. With no roots to offer her stability, Fister moved around the country and eventually, year-old Diane settled in Jefferson, Wisconsin, a picturesque little town. Fister took a job as an office clerk and in a lumber mill. It was here that Fister met carpenter Ruben Borchardt. Soon Fister wed husband. Diane Borchardt. For his part, Borchardt had also been married once before but he was tragically widowed when his wife was killed in a car accident in front of their home. He was left with two children. Nobody bought it. Diane and Ruben soon had their own daughter, named Regan. Diane now had no interest in her stepchildren. She treated them poorly, kind at one minute, cruel the next. Chuck brought police to the still-conscious victim, seated in his blood-soaked armchair. Police investigated the Borchardt household. They discovered the shooting had taken place in the basement. Somehow, Ruben had managed to pull himself upstairs to fall into a chair in the living room. Chuck was the only other person in the house that evening. He and his father were both hunters. Naturally Chuck fell under suspicion. Police went to speak to Diane and discovered she and Ruben had been involved in an acrimonious divorce. Diane had been in Tomahawk Wisconsin. Soon Diane became the sole suspect in the crime. Chuck agreed to be hypnotized but he reiterated the same story. She was a loyal wife and actively involved in the community. She was a good and caring person. She could be vicious when she was angry. Over the following few months however Ruben became fearful, believing Diane might be preparing to hurt him. Ruben won access to Chuck and he was awarded the house. Instead of celebrating, Ruben decided he would give the house to Diane, believing she would indeed kill him. Two weeks later, Ruben was dead. Four months passed. There was no break in the case. Douglas Vest, Michael Maldanado, his cousin, and Josh Yanke, all sophomores at the school where Diane volunteered as a study hall monitor, were all suggested as being the killers. It was Diane who had recruited the gullible teenagers into committing the murder. Diane however, protested her innocence. During the interrogation of the boys, police learned Vest was an easy mark. He believed Diane when she told him how unfairly she was being treated. He recruited his two friends to kill Ruben. After entering the Borchardt household, Moldanado and Vest went downstairs to shoot Ruben. Yanke took the phone off the hook. On the stairway, Moldanado and Vest encountered Borchardt. Moldanado shot him twice. By striking deals with the boys, the DA gathered significant evidence against Diane.